About OTM Cafe

Welcome to Old Town Mexican Cafe, a culinary haven located in the heart of Key West, Florida, where we've been delighting locals and visitors alike with our innovative take on Southwest and authentic Mexican cuisine since 1999. Under the creative guidance of Chef Gail Brockway, our award-winning menu offers a departure from the typical Tex-Mex fare, providing a unique and memorable dining experience.

Step into our inviting space and be transported to a world where the vibrant flavors of Sante Fe-inspired dishes blend seamlessly with the tropical charm of Key West. Our commitment to culinary excellence extends beyond the plate to our tequila bar, home to an impressive collection of over 200 tequilas. Each bottle tells a story and invites you to embark on a journey through the diverse and nuanced world of tequila.

With our prime location on historic Duval Street, you'll have a front-row seat for some of the best people-watching in Key West. And when you need a break from the tropical heat, our cool air-conditioned dining area offers the perfect respite.

But that's not all - we also cater to dietary preferences, offering a variety of vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. Whether you're a local seeking a culinary adventure or a visitor in search of an extraordinary dining experience, Old Town Mexican Cafe welcomes you to savor the fusion of flavors on historic Duval Street. Join us as we continue to celebrate the essence of Mexican cuisine and hospitality, sharing our passion with the community we've been a part of since 1999.


our vision

At Old Town Mexican Cafe, our vision is crafted from Chef Gail Brockway’s deep passion for Mexican cuisine, a commitment to health-conscious dining, and the unwavering belief that each guest deserves an extraordinary experience. Our core values are the guiding principles that define our identity and shape the atmosphere we strive to create.

  • Dedication to the art of southwestern cuisine is at the heart of our vision. Chef Gail’s passion infuses every dish with vibrant flavors, offering a celebration of health and deliciousness on every plate.
  • Exceptional service is the cornerstone of our vision. From the moment you step through our doors, our team is dedicated to ensuring your time with us is nothing short of extraordinary.
  • We believe in treating everyone in our company with equal respect, recognizing the unique worth each individual brings to our culinary family.
Banana Enchilada